--- name: receiving-code-review description: Evaluate review feedback technically before acting; fix correct items and push back on incorrect ones with codebase evidence permalink: opencode-config/skills/receiving-code-review/skill --- # Receiving Code Review Feedback ## Core Workflow When feedback arrives, follow this order: 1. **Read fully** before reacting. 2. **Understand the actual requirement** (restate it or ask a clarifying question). 3. **Verify against codebase reality** (current behavior, constraints, tests, compatibility). 4. **Decide whether feedback is correct for this codebase**. 5. **Then act**: implement the fix, or push back with technical reasoning. ## Guardrails - Do not use performative praise or agreement. - Do not promise fixes before verification. - If any feedback is unclear, clarify first instead of partially implementing items you do understand. ## Processing Multi-Item Feedback Apply items in this order: 1. Clarifications first. 2. Blocking/security issues. 3. Simpler items. 4. Complex items. Test each change as you go. ## When to Push Back Push back when a suggestion is incorrect for this codebase, breaks existing behavior, or ignores known constraints. Push back style: - Keep it technical and specific. - Reference concrete code/tests/constraints. - Propose a safer alternative when possible. ## When Feedback Is Correct Implement the fix and report the concrete change. Keep acknowledgments factual and concise; let verified code changes demonstrate agreement. ## Bottom Line Technical correctness comes first: verify, decide, then fix or push back.